Motor Finance Redress: An Opportunity for Automotive Retailers to Rethink Consumer Trust

102 Views

Motor finance redress is entering a new phase. Parts of the FCA’s motor finance consumer redress scheme remain suspended pending legal challenges scheduled to be heard between 16 February and 3 March 2027. However, lenders within the scheme should continue preparing and progressing complaints as far as possible, including identifying relevant agreements and gathering information about commission arrangements and disclosure practices, some of which may be held by brokers or dealers.

The response to redress is also becoming less uniform. Barclays Partner Finance has confirmed that it will make optional early settlement offers to some customers whose motor finance commission complaints were acknowledged on or before 1 October 2026. The offers will be calculated using the FCA scheme methodology and made on a full-and-final basis. The regulator supports lenders making such offers where customers are offered no less than they would receive through the scheme and are clearly informed of the consequences of acceptance, including that they cannot seek additional compensation later if the legal challenge ultimately produces a higher entitlement.

For regulated automotive retailers, the implications extend beyond historic redress. The underlying question is whether firms can demonstrate not simply that a sales process was followed but what customers were told, what they understood and whether commercial practices influenced the outcome.

More than three years after Consumer Duty came into force, many automotive retailers have moved beyond initial implementation. Sales processes have been reviewed, communications updated and staff trained. Attention now needs to turn to the outcomes those changes are producing in practice.

Joe Norburn, CEO of TCC Group, looks at what the experience of motor finance redress can teach the sector about evidence, incentives and the next phase of Consumer Duty scrutiny.

Redress and Consumer Duty expose the same challenge

Redress and Consumer Duty can easily be treated as two separate regulatory issues. One looks backwards at historic conduct, while the other focuses on the outcomes customers are receiving today. Consumer Duty does not apply retrospectively, and historic conduct must be judged against the legal and regulatory standards in force at the time.

The comparison here is therefore about evidence and governance: both expose a similar underlying challenge – the quality of evidence firms hold about how customers were treated.

The motor finance redress exercise requires lenders to reconstruct historic transactions and understand matters including commission arrangements and what was disclosed to customers. Even during the partial suspension, the FCA expects firms within the scheme to continue preparing and progressing complaints as far as possible.

Consumer Duty brings that question into the present: can firms within scope demonstrate that customers are receiving good outcomes now?

For dealers carrying out regulated activities, the distinction between process and outcome matters because a compliant process can only tell part of the story. A customer file may show that the correct documents were issued and the required steps followed, while saying relatively little about what the customer understood.

Someone might, for example, be comfortable with the monthly payment but have a much weaker grasp of the total amount payable, APR or implications of an agreed mileage allowance. A file may record that vulnerability was considered without showing whether the conversation changed in response to the customer’s circumstances.

That makes the evidence around the customer interaction increasingly important.

The focus is moving from process to judgement

The first phase of Consumer Duty produced plenty of visible activity. Firms reviewed governance arrangements, customer communications, training and quality assurance. Those changes were necessary, but the harder question is whether they are resulting in good customer outcomes.

The FCA’s 2026 review of consumer understanding reinforces that distinction. It found that some firms relied too heavily on limited indicators rather than a sufficiently broad evidence base. The regulator highlighted sources including call listening, complaints, surveys, comprehension checks and feedback from interactions.

For senior management, this makes oversight less straightforward. The question is no longer simply whether controls exist, but whether the business can identify where they are working, where standards vary and when intervention is needed.

That becomes particularly important for dealer groups operating across multiple sites. A policy designed centrally may be experienced very differently by customers on the showroom floor.

It is also where the connection with redress becomes significant. Trying to establish several years later what happened during an individual customer journey is considerably harder if the evidence primarily shows documents, process stages and signatures rather than the substance of the interaction.

Consumer Duty provides an opportunity to identify and address that evidence gap now.

Fair value brings commercial pressures into the picture

Fair value is one area where automotive retailers have already seen the practical consequences of Consumer Duty scrutiny. Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) insurance provided a particularly visible example of the FCA challenging whether products represented value for customers. Following FCA requests, multiple firms agreed to pause sales, with several subsequently permitted to restart after demonstrating changes intended to improve fair value, including materially lower commission levels.

The FCA’s October 2026 review of fair value in consumer finance reinforces that firms should assess, evidence and monitor fair value, using judgement and an approach proportionate to their business, products and customers.

Where regulated products sold alongside a vehicle provide meaningful margin, firms need to understand why the price represents fair value and what evidence supports that judgement.

Incentives deserve the same attention.

Historic motor finance commission arrangements show how commercial incentives can influence customer interactions in ways that may be difficult to identify retrospectively.

A business may have strong Consumer Duty policies while rewarding sales teams primarily for finance penetration or the sale of particular add-ons. That creates a potential tension if the commercial signals staff receive point in a different direction from the customer outcomes senior management expects.

There is nothing inherently problematic about rewarding sales performance. What matters is ensuring the commercial incentive does not outweigh the obligation to deliver appropriate customer outcomes.

Boards therefore need to understand what incentive structures encourage in practice. If a scheme changes how products are positioned or explained, that is relevant to the resulting customer outcome and should be visible through the firm’s oversight.

The evidence gap sits in the showroom

Much of the behaviour that determines a customer’s experience takes place in conversation on the showroom floor, while traditional assurance can concentrate heavily on the paperwork left behind.

File sampling can establish whether documents are complete and expected steps have been followed. It may not reveal that a customer repeatedly struggled to understand part of the agreement, that a salesperson concentrated heavily on the monthly payment or that a vulnerability cue was missed.

For a dealer group, relying predominantly on the file can therefore leave a gap between the sales process head office believes is happening and what customers actually experience across its sites.

Firms should consider how they obtain better evidence of those interactions. That could include targeted conversation monitoring, customer-understanding testing, complaints and cancellation analysis, thematic quality assurance, and outcome testing across sites, products and customer groups. This is consistent with the FCA’s emphasis on using multiple sources of evidence to understand where consumers may be struggling, although the regulator makes clear that its good-practice examples do not create new regulatory requirements.

Conversation monitoring can provide another layer of evidence, showing where explanations are being missed, where customers appear uncertain and where treatment differs between teams or locations. Used effectively, it can support coaching and earlier intervention rather than simply producing another set of retrospective compliance statistics.

Recording customer conversations may raise concerns around privacy, retention, staff engagement and how findings are used. It should be treated as a change to the operating model rather than simply a technology purchase. Collecting more information has little value if the firm has not decided what it is looking for or how it will respond when problems appear.

This does not mean every interaction must be recorded. Firms should adopt a proportionate, risk-based approach to monitoring and evidence, taking account of their activities, customer base and ability to influence outcomes.

Do not rebuild the same evidence gap

Redress will understandably remain a major operational and regulatory priority for the motor finance sector. The FCA’s scheme concerns eligible motor finance agreements entered into between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, and the continuing legal challenges mean significant uncertainty remains around its implementation.

Reconstructing a customer interaction years after it happened is difficult, particularly where the available evidence shows which documents were provided or signed but gives much less insight into the conversation surrounding them.

Consumer Duty gives automotive retailers an opportunity to address that weakness earlier.

The response will look different depending on the size and structure of the business, but firms should be asking where customer outcomes vary, whether commercial incentives are influencing behaviour, what their assurance activity actually tells them and whether management information reflects what customers experience.

A useful test for any dealer group is therefore not simply whether it could demonstrate compliance today. It is whether, several years from now, it could reconstruct a customer interaction taking place today and explain, with evidence, why the outcome was fair.